← SimulatorFR

Frequently asked questions

The ten questions we are asked most often. Tap a question to read the answer.

1What exactly does ENRgy Maps show?

ENRgy Maps shows how Europe would produce its electricity, hour by hour, if it had a generation fleet far more renewable than today’s.

We start from the real weather and the real electricity demand of each country, and look at what a simulated fleet would do: which power plants run, how much electricity is stored or exchanged between countries, and how much CO₂ is emitted. The map therefore shows the current power grid, but not actual generation.

2Are the figures shown real?

Partly. Electricity demand and the weather (wind, sun, temperatures) are real: they come from the European grid operators (ENTSO-E, Elexon, NESO) and from the European weather centre (ECMWF).

Generation, on the other hand, is calculated: it is that of the simulated fleet, which starts from today’s fleet with modifications.

3Can a highly renewable Europe hold up when there is neither wind nor sun?

That is precisely what the simulator checks, hour by hour. Several levers take over when wind and sun are lacking: reservoirs and pumped hydro, batteries, biomass and biogas burned in power plants, and exchanges between countries (when there is no wind in Germany, there often is elsewhere).

The fleets are sized on a full year of weather (2025), including its worst winter weeks. The simulator then computes each day, hour by hour, with the real weather, and flags any unserved demand. For harsher winters, a stress test replays the fleets on the tightest weather years of 2016-2025 (2017, 2022, 2024) and on 2025, and adds biogas backup turbines wherever part of the demand would not have been served (50 GW for the 100% renewable fleet, 72 GW for the zero-fossil fleet). The guarantee remains limited to the replayed years.

4How much would such a system cost?

For the whole of modelled Europe, the annual cost of the power system (investments repaid over their lifetime, maintenance, fuel and CO₂) is about €258bn a year for a 100% renewable fleet with no nuclear, including grid reinforcement and the backup turbines added by the stress test. The zero-fossil fleet that keeps existing nuclear (79% renewables) costs about €234bn a year, and the current fleet about €279bn a year at the average 2026-2028 gas price (November 2026 computation campaign, 2025 weather year).

These amounts cover generation, storage and exchanges. The reinforcement of the power grid required by the arrival of large amounts of solar and wind is counted in all three scenarios (€100/kW of solar and onshore wind installed). The observatory compares the three scenarios with one another.

5What does a tonne of CO₂ avoided cost?

Each fleet is compared with the current fleet: cost difference divided by the CO₂ avoided over the life cycle. At the average 2026-2028 gas price, both fossil-free fleets are both cheaper and lower-emitting than the current fleet: there is no cost per tonne avoided, but a saving. The “renewables + current nuclear” fleet saves about €46bn a year and avoids about 458 MtCO₂e a year; the 100% renewable fleet saves about €21bn a year and avoids about 440 MtCO₂e a year.

With gas at the low 2025 price (€36/MWh), the zero-fossil fleet is still cheaper than the current fleet; the 100% renewable fleet costs about €2bn a year more, i.e. about €5 per tonne of CO₂ avoided. These costs include the CO₂ price (€78.59/t) paid by the fossil plants of the current fleet.

Between the two fossil-free fleets, 100% renewable costs about €25bn a year more and emits slightly more over the life cycle (105 versus 87 MtCO₂e a year: nuclear, at 12 gCO₂e/kWh, is replaced by solar and biomass): so there is no abatement cost between them. Details are in the observatory.

Moreover, the value of climate action, that is the price we should be willing to pay to avoid emitting one tonne of CO₂, is €250/tCO₂ if we are to meet our climate commitments. Both fossil-free fleets are far below that.

6And where does nuclear fit into all this?

The simulator offers three fleets, chosen in the “Scenario” box: the current fleet, a zero-fossil fleet that keeps existing nuclear (79% renewables), and a 100% renewable fleet, where existing reactors are retired.

The zero-fossil fleet with existing nuclear is the cheapest of the three and the lowest-emitting over the life cycle. Showing fleets with and without nuclear is not taking sides: it is what makes comparison possible.

7What does “curtailment” mean?

It is solar and wind electricity that could have been produced but is not, because at that moment nobody can use it: demand is met, storage is full and neighbouring countries do not need it.

It is an economic choice: it is often cheaper to install slightly too many panels and wind turbines, and to lose part of their output during surplus hours, than to build giant storage. In the simulated scenarios, curtailment amounts to a few percent of potential generation, more when the target is 100%.

8How often is the map updated?

Every evening. As soon as the new European weather forecast is published, the simulator computes the following day for each scenario, from the forecast weather and the demand forecast by the grid operators. The site is updated at around 11:30 pm in summer and 10:30 pm in winter (Paris time).

Past days remain available: the timeline at the bottom of the map lets you go back hour by hour, day by day, month by month or year by year.

9Why is carbon intensity not zero at 100% renewables?

Carbon intensity, expressed in grams of CO₂ per kilowatt-hour (gCO₂e/kWh), counts emissions over the whole life cycle of the installations: manufacturing panels and wind turbines, building dams, growing biomass, decommissioning. Even without burning any fossil fuel, each kWh therefore carries a small footprint, of the order of a few tens of grams.

For comparison, a gas-fired power plant emits about 490 gCO₂e/kWh and a coal-fired plant more than 800. The values used are the medians published by the IPCC.

These life-cycle emissions will fall as the economy decarbonises. For example, about 80% of the energy needed to manufacture a solar panel is electricity1: the more the global electricity mix decarbonises, the more solar emissions fall.

10What are the limitations of these results?

Like any model, this one simplifies. The main limitations: a single weather year to size the fleets (completed by the stress test on the tightest years), the current power grid without planned lines for today's demand, the cost of grid reinforcement estimated as a flat €100/kW, and assumptions about storage and reservoirs that are labelled as such.

The full method is public on the Method page. Comments, criticism and corrections are welcome: they help improve the model.

1. IEA, Special Report on Solar PV Global Supply Chains, 2022, p. 37.